The 2024 NFL regular season has concluded, ushering in the awards season. However, not all reactions to these accolades are favorable. Within the Philadelphia Eagles organization, discontent surfaced after right tackle Lane Johnson was again overlooked for the league’s first-team All-Pro right tackle spot, which went to Detroit Lions’ Penei Sewell for the second consecutive season. This decision sparked controversy, with Johnson’s dissatisfaction subtly expressed through a locker room sign comparing his and Sewell’s performance metrics.
Prior to the Eagles’ playoff game against the Green Bay Packers, an “All-Pro Comparison” chart at Johnson’s locker highlighted disparities between his and Sewell’s performances. Though the creator of the sign remains unidentified, Johnson acknowledged the comparison chart. The chart underscored Johnson’s disappointment with the All-Pro voting process, which seemingly undervalued his standout contributions.
CBS Sports reviewed the statistics from Johnson’s comparison and found the data mostly accurate, though some discrepancies were noted. Additionally, Pro Football Focus (PFF) grades, a metric considered by many voters, were missing from the chart. Sewell outperformed Johnson in overall PFF offensive grade (87.5 vs. 85.4) and run-blocking grade (90.5 vs. 80.0), while Johnson had the edge in PFF pass-blocking grade (88.1 vs. 74.1). These differences may have influenced the final All-Pro decision.
The ongoing debate underscores the tight competition between Johnson and Sewell. If the Eagles and Lions face off in the NFC Championship, the matchup could carry extra intrigue, showcasing the league’s top two right tackles.
Lane Johnson vs. Penei Sewell Comparison
| Stats Comparison | Lane Johnson (PHI) | Penei Sewell (DET) |
|---|---|---|
| Sacks allowed | 0 | 1 |
| QB hits allowed | 1 | 5 |
| QB pressures allowed | 6 | 25 |
| Pass block win rate | 94% | 91% |
| Island rate | 75% (1st) | 55% (58th) |
| QB time to throw average | 3.31 seconds | 2.88 seconds |
| Run block win rate | 80% | Not Ranked |
| Team rushing yards | 3,048 | 2,488 |
This table highlights the statistical achievements of both players, with Johnson excelling in several categories, though missing the All-Pro recognition.